ROOF RACKS Bed Rack vs Roof Rack

  • Hello, visitor! Welcome to Tacoma3G.com, a resource for 3rd Generation Toyota Tacoma owners.

    Tacoma3G is a friendly community dedicated to 2016-2021 Toyota Tacoma and Overland Enthusiasts. Registration is completely free and only takes 30 seconds, so we hope to see you and your rig soon!

Manbun525

✓ • Gold
Messages
99
Upvotes Recieved
102
Location
Phoenix, AZ
First Name
Jake
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Inferno
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#259
Opinions on which is better? I would like to get both down the road, currently looking at the RCI bed rack and Prinsu roof rack. Open to see what all you guys have, prices, pros/cons etc. Would like a RTT soon too, can a roof rack supports this just as well as the bed rack?

Thanks
 
S

SDyota_66

Unregistered or Deleted User
Love my Frontrunner. Sits below the cab for aero and easy to reach stuff, but high enough I can put the cooler etc, in the bottom. Lock the tail gate and stuff is secured underneath so people can't just pull it out.

IMG_2336.JPG
IMG_2981.JPG
IMG_3012.JPG
 

mcharfauros

✓ • Diamond
Tacoma3G Supporter
Messages
294
Upvotes Recieved
570
First Name
Mike
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Midnight Black
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Manual
T3G Member
#494
diggin your setup, could see my family and I throwing an Oztent or a couple of swags up top, with gear below the rack line.
 
S

SDyota_66

Unregistered or Deleted User
diggin your setup, could see my family and I throwing an Oztent or a couple of swags up top, with gear below the rack line.
Thank you. That was the plane for us. RTT and ready to go any time, but the wife decided she didn't want an RTT and my dog weighs 100 lbs. So now I use a soft pack to keep our sleeping bags etc dust free and ground camp. I would definitely recommend bed stiffeners if you put any kind of weight up top. Also, since this bolts right onto the bed rails, I don't know how much weight those hold.
 

Malcolm

✓ • Aficionado
Tacoma3G Supporter
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
821
Upvotes Recieved
1,402
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Cement
Truck Grade
Pro
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#15
Roof rack can support those yes. But it is not ideal. Having the tent on the roof creates a lot of drag, which is why a mid height bed rack or low height is ideal. Aside from drag, mounting on the roof creates excess height which can hinder you on some trails or certain areas. Bed rack makes everything easier and gives you mounting options as well. It would be best to get a roof rack as a secondary storage or mounting option rather than somewhere to mount a RTT
 

bajatacoguy

✓ • Bronze
Messages
3
Upvotes Recieved
2
First Name
Johnny
T3G Member
#890
i would start with the bed rack because the are more versatile but go quality not the crappy KB Voodoo.
 

Tyler

✓ • Paragon
Badministrator
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
6,215
Upvotes Recieved
9,998
Location
Long Island, NY
First Name
Tyler
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Quicksand
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#1
Roof rack can support those yes. But it is not ideal. Having the tent on the roof creates a lot of drag, which is why a mid height bed rack or low height is ideal. Aside from drag, mounting on the roof creates excess height which can hinder you on some trails or certain areas. Bed rack makes everything easier and gives you mounting options as well. It would be best to get a roof rack as a secondary storage or mounting option rather than somewhere to mount a RTT
Basically this. You’ll hardly ever see a RTT on the roof of a Taco because there aren’t many benefits to it. Unless you’re me and use the bed all the time for large shit/have to stand in the bed a lot. And just really, really prefer to maintain the traditional pickup truck look.

http://instagr.am/p/BmzspV4Hrf3/
 

DrWeld

✓ • Silver
Messages
38
Upvotes Recieved
79
Location
San Diego
First Name
Robert
Truck Year
2018
Truck Color
Cement
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#396
I like bed racks that are functional and looks good at the same time. That’s why I designed and built my own. I don’t have an RTT yet but will soon and it was designed with that in mind. The cool thing as that it’s always a work in progress.
D9038F9C-B544-4E2E-A614-E23BCF8B47B9.jpeg
3C9E0200-CFC0-49B3-A424-277961D84DF0.jpeg
 

AZ_CAVALRY

✓ • Diamond
Rig of the Month
Messages
317
Upvotes Recieved
551
Location
Tolleson, AZ
First Name
Josh
Truck Year
2019
Truck Color
Cavalry Blue
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#309
I love my rack from KB Voodoo/Max Modular. It has the crossbars to support my tent, jack, and whatever else I want to attach. Plenty of mounting points, and I've beat the crap out of it on the trails. It's held up great, and i can still use my tonneau cover with it. Lots of good things to say.
1546531318869.png
 

Tyler

✓ • Paragon
Badministrator
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
6,215
Upvotes Recieved
9,998
Location
Long Island, NY
First Name
Tyler
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Quicksand
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#1
I like bed racks that are functional and looks good at the same time. That’s why I designed and built my own. I don’t have an RTT yet but will soon and it was designed with that in mind. The cool thing as that it’s always a work in progress.
D9038F9C-B544-4E2E-A614-E23BCF8B47B9.jpeg
3C9E0200-CFC0-49B3-A424-277961D84DF0.jpeg
Yours looks super solid dude. I would rock one if I end up going this route.
 

Tacocamper

✓ • Gold
Messages
161
Upvotes Recieved
186
T3G Member
#2,384
Opinions on which is better? I would like to get both down the road, currently looking at the RCI bed rack and Prinsu roof rack. Open to see what all you guys have, prices, pros/cons etc. Would like a RTT soon too, can a roof rack supports this just as well as the bed rack?

Thanks


Go with both! I went with both (RCI bed rack and Prinsu cab rack). Probably would never mount my RTT on the cab due to what was said above about the drag.
The only con I have is the wind noise at high speeds with the Prinsu. Other thank that they are both solid products.
 

RevN3

✓ • Diamond
Rig of the Month
Tacoma3G Supporter
Messages
700
Upvotes Recieved
874
Location
Eugene, Oregon
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Blazing Blue Pearl
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Manual
T3G Member
#1,323
I like bed racks that are functional and looks good at the same time. That’s why I designed and built my own. I don’t have an RTT yet but will soon and it was designed with that in mind. The cool thing as that it’s always a work in progress.

Oh! Those are sweet. I don't suppose you have any design docs do you? I have the means and motive to make something like that.
 

Truck Brigade

truckbrigade.com
Authorized Vendor
Tacoma3G Supporter
Messages
76
Upvotes Recieved
98
First Name
Ryan & TJ
T3G Member
#2,412
Wouldnt say one is necessarily better than the other. Depending on how you envisioning setting up your rig, they can both serve different purposes. We have experience with the RCI rack and think it is a great rack. It is more affordable than many out there and the lead times are manageable. Also, can't go wrong with a PrinSu roof rack!
 

DrWeld

✓ • Silver
Messages
38
Upvotes Recieved
79
Location
San Diego
First Name
Robert
Truck Year
2018
Truck Color
Cement
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#396
Oh! Those are sweet. I don't suppose you have any design docs do you? I have the means and motive to make something like that.
Pm me
 

Malcolm

✓ • Aficionado
Tacoma3G Supporter
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
821
Upvotes Recieved
1,402
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Cement
Truck Grade
Pro
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#15
They both have different applications that i think are important to note. your roof rack should really be utilized for storage such as dry boxes, rifle cases, dry bags, lighting, etc. Your bed rack really should be more accessory oriented to include tents, shovels, traction boards , whatever you really feel like. Having bulky items on the roof creates drag and wind noise, which may not be bad at first but you will grow tired of it. It is nice to have a bed rack that is about mid height and comes below the height of your cab just so you dont get that excess drag.

This is just my personal opinion and advice, just thought i would lay those points out.
 

Mr. Nobody

✓ • Connoisseur
Tacoma3G Supporter
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
2,181
Upvotes Recieved
3,027
Location
San Diego, CA
First Name
Andy
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Quicksand
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#184
The thing that gets overlooked one versus the other is how do you store your gear. If you need your gear to remain cleaner and drier then a shell with a rack is probably going to accomplish that better. If you don't mind the dust and water having a bit more access to your stuff, or like to travel much lighter, then a bed rack is probably the way to go. In the end it's all personal preference as either way can accomplish goals, it's more just how you plan to use your stuff.

That said I went with a shell. I seem to be becoming the minority more and more. Nothing wrong with all the options out there, jut the shell works for me, especially day to day. I'm pretty happy with how it worked out.

JTreeBerdoo-45.jpg
 

Manbun525

✓ • Gold
Messages
99
Upvotes Recieved
102
Location
Phoenix, AZ
First Name
Jake
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Inferno
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#259
The thing that gets overlooked one versus the other is how do you store your gear. If you need your gear to remain cleaner and drier then a shell with a rack is probably going to accomplish that better. If you don't mind the dust and water having a bit more access to your stuff, or like to travel much lighter, then a bed rack is probably the way to go. In the end it's all personal preference as either way can accomplish goals, it's more just how you plan to use your stuff.

That said I went with a shell. I seem to be becoming the minority more and more. Nothing wrong with all the options out there, jut the shell works for me, especially day to day. I'm pretty happy with how it worked out.

JTreeBerdoo-45.jpg

As of now I plan to do the Prinsu Cabrack and possibly just a mx4 bed cover, I love the look and style of the camper shell (although the girl thinks it looks like an old man truck like that) but what kept me away from the shell is loading or hauling large objects in the bed of my truck, like moving furniture, beds, dresser, couches etc or other large objects that wont fit under the shell. Also the convenience of just being able to load and throw crap in the bed of my truck from either side without the windows or back loading. The mx4 folds up so the bed can be completely open if need be, can cover, lock and be waterproof as well. Most of my utility/recover gear and tools will go on my roof rack while my bed will be for either sleeping and or camping and personal gear.
 

Mr. Nobody

✓ • Connoisseur
Tacoma3G Supporter
Tacoma3G O.G.
Messages
2,181
Upvotes Recieved
3,027
Location
San Diego, CA
First Name
Andy
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Quicksand
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Long Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#184
As of now I plan to do the Prinsu Cabrack and possibly just a mx4 bed cover, I love the look and style of the camper shell (although the girl thinks it looks like an old man truck like that) but what kept me away from the shell is loading or hauling large objects in the bed of my truck, like moving furniture, beds, dresser, couches etc or other large objects that wont fit under the shell. Also the convenience of just being able to load and throw crap in the bed of my truck from either side without the windows or back loading. The mx4 folds up so the bed can be completely open if need be, can cover, lock and be waterproof as well. Most of my utility/recover gear and tools will go on my roof rack while my bed will be for either sleeping and or camping and personal gear.


And that it's right there. People need to analyze their planned usage for the truck, and it seems you have. I load a lot of stuff into my truck, but most all of it will regularly fit inside a shell.
 

skylerizzo

✓ • Bronze
Tacoma3G Supporter
Messages
13
Upvotes Recieved
5
Location
New Jersey
First Name
Skyler
Truck Year
2018
Truck Color
Magnetic Gray
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#2,376
Basically this. You’ll hardly ever see a RTT on the roof of a Taco because there aren’t many benefits to it. Unless you’re me and use the bed all the time for large shit/have to stand in the bed a lot. And just really, really prefer to maintain the traditional pickup truck look.

http://instagr.am/p/BmzspV4Hrf3/

Is it hard to take off the RTT? Was planning on getting a RTT for the Cab on top the Prinsu, but i also use my truck as a commuter to work so i’d only be using the RTT on the weekend for beach trips/ camp trips.
 

ShikyoX

✓ • Diamond
Tacoma3G Supporter
Messages
823
Upvotes Recieved
712
Location
B.C Canada
First Name
Trevor
Truck Year
2017
Truck Color
Magnetic Gray
Truck Grade
Off-Road
Cab & Bed
Double Cab, Short Bed
Transmission
Automatic
T3G Member
#310
Is it hard to take off the RTT? Was planning on getting a RTT for the Cab on top the Prinsu, but i also use my truck as a commuter to work so i’d only be using the RTT on the weekend for beach trips/ camp trips.
Rtt are a 2 man job usually there a tad heavy and the height doesn't help at all
 
Top Bottom